Fiter -> Sketch -> Chalk and Charcoal
Charcoal Area: 3
Chalk Area: 20
Stroke Pressure: 2



Filter -> Blur -> Motion Blur
Angle: 0
Distance: 9



Thats it for filters, now right click the circle layer and press Blending Options. Apply these two settings on there and hit OK!

Drop Shadow
Bevel and Emboss

This should be similar to what you have now.


Press CTRL+T to transform the image. Hold shift to maintain its proportion and make it as small as possible. About 10x10 infact, now onto the fun part!